In Science Fiction, I've always known that war/conflict, and culture played a part. This is probably my least favorite part of this genre. I appreciate that almost all scifi stories teach a lesson or a moral that should be followed. But honestly, I love Science Fiction because of the fantastical world it can take you to and the wonderful things that can happen regardless of what is humanly possible in our world. This week I read the stories "That Only a Mother" by Judith Merril and "We See Things Differently" by Bruce Sterling. I think I have to admit that these are not going to go down in my record books as 'scifi stories I thoroughly enjoyed'. That being said, I will continue with my analysis of these stories.
In "That Only a Mother" I found it a very interesting literary choice that the author decided to include telegrams only from Maggie, she never included the ones back from Hank, only when he said he was coming home, and one before the baby was born. Obviously, after I had finished the story it made more sense to me why Merril did this. Although I said I wasn't a huge fan of the 'War and Conflict" side of scifi, these kinds of endings are why I appreciate the genre so much. I thought it was amazing (yet strange) how this baby could speak and sing so beautifully, especially at such a young age. But, the second I thought about how abnormal (not in a negative way) this was, I realized that I knew from experience, typically when one sense of the body overly develops, very quickly, it means that there is something wrong with another one. In this specific case, the talent and ability of speech and understanding, advanced because of the lack of touch/feel and movement.
"That Only a Mother" didn't conform to the scifi standard, area and setting wise, especially because it wasn't in the future and there was nothing strange about their society. However, the second that the big "secret" was revealed at the end, a whole new layer of Science Fiction standards were added. Suddenly when you find out that the baby is disabled, it causes you as a reader to think back to all of the things that the mother was saying before, how absolutely sure she was that her baby was PERFECT. You begin to consider if her blindness to her baby's disability was a shear act of love, or if it was borderline madness/insanity because she wanted so badly for her baby to be perfect. Of course because this is Science Fiction, Merril had to add in the part of Hank saying "Why didn't you tell me" and Maggie responds as if she had no idea of what he meant. As a reader, I couldn't help but be amazed and rather awe-struck at this point because like I said before, I
love endings like this.
Aside from the aspect of insanity that was included in "That Only a Mother", there was something beautiful that must be taken into perspective. Regardless of the fact that Maggie's daughter was disabled(I really hate the term mutated, although that was the word in the book) she had unconditional love for her. Maggie thought she was just as beautiful and as perfect, if not more, than any other little girl. I think that this is true for all parents of disabled children. During the time period that this was written (1948) there were so many cases where disabled children were disposed of, or given up by their parents. Even some hospitals would try to starve out the babies and refuse treatment because they were 'an abomination' or 'freaks'. I really appreciated and enjoyed that the author took the opposite view point and spoke about how a mother could and would love her child, and be blind to their irregularities, it was a beautiful concept.
I was really not captured by the way that Sterling wrote "We See Things Differently", I feel like the first 5-7 pages were very slow, the author is
very descriptive and thorough with imagery. While some readers may enjoy this, I really did not.Like I said before, it doesn't help that I'm not enthralled with this branch of Science Fiction. That being said, I really did enjoy the lesson that this story was trying to convey. While reading the whole story, the theme behind the title was very clear to see. Because this man had come so far from a completely different culture into American, it was easy to understand why there was a big element of culture shock. I think this story could be applied to society today in more ways than one. There is a huge level of ignorance that a vast majority of Americans still exemplify today. This ignorance is a huge factor behind world conflict, and the lack of sensitivity towards other cultures. I did enjoy that although "Charlie" had been exposed to so many types of offensive, rude, ignorance, he still kept the peace for the most part. In the end he kind of alluded to the fact that everyone has their own troubles and their own ignorance, but man should not judge man of these things because your issues, and your ignorance are what are most important to you. I believe that a lot of this has to do with human instinct an that it will continue as long as humans walk the Earth.
"I finally got to see her! It's all true, what they say about new babies and the face that only a mother could love- but it's all there, darling, eyes, ears and noses -no, only one! - all in the right places. We're so lucky, Hank" - Maggie "That Only a Mother" by Judith Merril.
Update: Okay so just a few things I failed to notice while reading "That Only a Mother". I've reread the story since I posted this and had a class discussion. Now that I've reread, it occurs to me much sooner that the baby is mutated. For example, how in the quote I posted, Maggie only talks about her babies facial features. This is a huge
red flag, that there is something wrong with the rest of the baby. Also, there are quite a few subtle but clear references to fathers murdering their babies after seeing them with their mutations. It was mentioned how the fathers were never taken to trial with these murders because it was so common and medical oddities were not protected during these years. This is very true and accurate for this time period in history, disabilities were frowned upon and often discarded or overlooked in the eyes of society. Through all of these subtle hints it can be inferred at the end that the father was going to attempt to kill his child. Although this is a very important part of the story and was most likely intended to be assumed, I'm kind of happy I over looked it the first time. I love scifi and a good surprise ending even if it is a little morbid but I think this was a little too dark for my own personal preference.